Creatine,
Caffeine, and Carbohydrates - Supplements That Work
By David Petersen
It would seem that everyone is looking to squeeze the most out of
their training investment and as a result, the supplement industry
has globally become a multi-billion dollar industry. There are however
very few legal ergogenic (performance enhancing) supplements on
the market whose benefits are proven and whose negative side effects
are minimal. A large majority of the supplements on the market are
either dangerous e.g.. Ephedrine or have absolutely no benefit at
all on performance e.g. orthonine, arginine. In this article we
have chosen to highlight three products, which have proven performance-enhancing
properties, these include creatine, caffeine and carbohydrates.
A product that has been
repeatedly shown to improve performance in power-type sports and
especially those that involve interval training is creatine. Creatine
is a combination of three different amino acids and is produced
naturally in the body, the vast majority being stored in skeletal
muscle as creatine phosphate. Creatine phosphate is able to maintain
muscle ATP (a high energy molecule and the energy “currency”
of the body) levels in muscle by “donating” its phosphate
to ADP (a lower energy molecule) thus allowing for an increased
reserve of instantaneous energy to be used during very high intensity
exercise. For example, creatine is likely to benefit high intensity
exercise such as weight/power training and repeated sprints/interval
training but not single sprint events lasting shorter than 90 seconds
and endurance competition. The American diet supplies about 1 gram
of creatine, which is found in red meat and some fish species (mackerel),
but studies have shown that supplementing with 20 grams of creatine
monophosphate for six days may increase muscle creatine levels by
20%. The recommended dosage is to take a “loading” dose
of approximately 20 grams (4 teaspoons) a day for 5 days; thereafter
a “maintenance” dose of 5-10 grams is required.
In addition, it is recommended
that the individual take the supplement dissolved in a drink of
high carbohydrate content (about 2 hours before exercise) as this
causes an insulin "spike" which assists in muscle creatine
uptake by more than half. It is proposed however that not all individuals
respond to the use of creatine equally – some respond well
by being able to store the additional quantities while others do
not seem able to do the same. Lastly, it is suspected that the use
of creatine is relatively safe although the long-term health risks
of high dose supplementation are unknown. The only drawbacks known
at this time is that it may cause stomach upset if not dissolved
properly and individuals with existing kidney disease should not
use it. Competing athletes are encouraged to use only high quality
products from an established supplier, as some manufacturers have
deliberately spiked their products with illegal performance enhancing
substances and steroid precursors such as nandrolone, while other
products may be contaminated with toxic metals.
There is a large
body of evidence to indicate that caffeine use even at levels below
that allowed during Olympic competition (>12 mg/ml) produces
several ergogenic effects. Studies involving cyclists performing
at a fixed intensity have demonstrated an increased time to fatigue
ranging from 20-50% when using the product. Also, caffeine improves
performance during all-out efforts lasting 4-5 minutes and during
repeated bouts of exercise such as interval training. Caffeine has
also been demonstrated to increase the maximum force that can be
sustained during a maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) of a muscle
and that the duration of sustaining an isometric contraction at
50% MVC increases on the order of 28%. It is proposed that this
effect is due to increased skeletal muscle recruitment by the motor
cortex of the brain, and that caffeine may also decrease the perception
of effort allowing for more relative work to be performed. Thus
caffeine may improve performance in a strength training routine.
Other proposed methods of its operation is that it reduces fatigue
and increases alertness and well-being which may be helpful during
events of extreme duration such as ultra marathons where staying
awake plays a crucial role in performance results. Some evidence
seems to indicate a glycogen sparing effect associated with the
use of caffeine, however its metabolic effects has not been substantiated.
Furthermore, it has been
demonstrated that caffeine does not increase urine production during
exercise, but does so at rest. Popular sources of caffeine are coffee
(50-100 mg/cup), cola drinks (50mg/375 ml can) and over the counter
medications (100-200 mg/tablet). It is possible that the tablet
source may produce more ergogenic effects on exercise as it is suspected
that other chemicals found in coffee may interfere with caffeine’s
operation. Caffeine should not be consumed in association with creatine
as there is some evidence to indicate that the former prevents the
latter’s absorption.
Although one may not
think of it as a supplement in the true sense of the word, as mentioned
previously in other articles and tips on this website, the use of
carbohydrate during and immediately after exercise has demonstrated
various ergogenic effects. Research has indicated that hypoglycemia
(low blood sugar) can be a significant cause of fatigue and premature
termination during prolonged exercise events. Consuming carbohydrates
during a race will not necessarily allow an individual to perform
better, but it will increase the time to fatigue should they not
have enough liver glycogen (stored glucose) to maintain blood sugar
levels for the duration. In a previous article on the lactate threshold/turnpoint
we discussed the fact that muscle glycogen is committed to be used
in its cell of storage. The liver however is capable of releasing
its glycogen stores as glucose into the blood stream to maintain
blood sugar levels. The liver glycogen reserves however are limited
– only about 100 grams, whereas the skeletal muscle is able
to store about 500 grams. It is estimated that during prolonged
exercise events such as marathons, the rate of blood glucose usage
is 1.0 gram per minute or 60 grams per hour. So assuming a non-carbohydrate
loaded participant enters such a competition even with full liver
glycogen stores, they would only be able to maintain blood sugar
levels for about an hour and a three quarters before hypoglycemia
would begin to set in.
Regular carbohydrate
ingestion during the race will help the participant to maintain
normal blood sugar levels and avoid fatigue and the early termination
associated with hypoglycemia. Another associated benefit of carbohydrate
ingestion during exercise is its protein sparing effect. During
aerobic or endurance type exercise, as muscle and liver glycogen
levels begin to fall, protein (source of amino acids) from muscle
stores is increasingly broken down to help replenish blood sugar
levels through gluconeogenesis (the production of glucose). With
the maintenance of blood sugar from ingested carbohydrates, less
protein and lean tissue mass is sacrificed. In addition it is suspected,
although still questionable at this point that carbohydrate consumption
may prevent central or neural fatigue by limiting the amount of
free tryptophan in the blood. Tryptophan is an amino acid from which
the substance serotonin (a substance which induces sleepiness and
fatigue in the brain) is made. Carbohydrate ingestion in combination
with protein immediately after intense exercise has been demonstrated
to increase protein/muscle synthesis and increase muscle glycogen
stores (glycogenesis). It is likely that the increased protein synthesis
is mediated by increased quantities of a hormone known as IGF-1
(Insulin-like Growth Factor-1). Lastly, as mentioned earlier carbohydrate
assists indirectly in the transport of creatine monophosphate into
skeletal muscle, thus increasing reserves of creatine phoshphate.
In conclusion, there
are some supplements that have proven ergogenic properties and are
presently considered safe. It is not advisable however to consume
all of these supplements together since one product may have negating
effects on the other. Unfortunately, the marketing of supplements
often far exceeds the potential benefits to be gained. The consumer
should carefully consider the energy and metabolic demands of their
sport/event or alternatively consult the services of an experienced
exercise professional. This will allow the individual to choose
the supplement that best suits their needs and avoid spending money
on potentially useless products or risking their health or competition
status.
David Petersen is a Personal
Trainer/Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist and the owner
and founder of B.O.S.S. Fitness Inc. based in Oldsmar, Florida.
More articles and information can be found at http://www.bossfitness.com
NOTE: You're free to
republish this article on your website, in your newsletter, in your
e-book or in other publications provided the article is reproduced
in its entirety, including this note, author information and all
LIVE website links as above.
Article Source: http://EzineArticles.com/?expert=David_Petersen
|